Share

Did You Know?

Although people of color make up about one third of the population, they make up 46.1 percent of pedestrian deaths.

Report shows mayor, police drove decisions to shut down transit, raise bridges

Feb 24, 2021 | by Kyle Whitehead

A new report from Chicago’s Inspector General (IG) finds police and emergency management personnel had outsize influence on decisions to shut down transit and raise bridges during last summer’s protests following George Floyd’s murder.

These decisions had major transportation impacts on thousands of city residents, particularly our most vulnerable neighbors such as people with disabilities and low-income essential workers.

Yet the report finds the city’s transit leaders who know their systems best often weren’t at the table when these calls were made. 

REPORT FINDINGS 

  • On decisions to shut down transit: “CTA personnel expressed doubts as to whether CPD command staff knew the CTA system well enough to know what service changes would achieve the desired crowd control objectives.” (p. 43)
  • On downtown stop closures: “The decision to bypass downtown CTA stops was made by the Mayor’s Office at the recommendation of CPD senior command staff…One command staff member specifically mentioned stopping people coming from the City’s South Side as an objective.” (p. 43)
  • On rerouting buses: “CTA personnel were occasionally asked to do things that were not operationally feasible; for example, there was a push to get people out of downtown, but bus and train services into and out of the area had been stopped. CTA had to make the case to allow some buses to run in order to get people out of downtown.” (p. 44)
  • On raising bridges: “There was no standing plan to do so… During protests at the 2012 North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) summit in Chicago, raising bridges had been discussed and rejected as an ineffective tool for emergency crowd control.” (p. 37)

IMPACT OF SHUTDOWNS 

In the days following the protests, Active Trans connected with city residents harmed by the public transit and Divvy shutdowns. We heard from people who had to walk several miles or bike as many as 25 miles to get home from work or visit family members in need during the pandemic. Others paid more than $30 for an Uber or Lyft, only to arrive late to work and lose needed income.

People with disabilities who rely on paratransit to get around weren’t able to get groceries or seek medical care. Due to the way transit bylaws are structured, paratransit can’t operate if buses and trains are not running.

The most impacted residents were disproportionately Black and Brown and low-income and people with disabilities.

These residents are more likely to rely on transit to get around and perform essential work that doesn’t fit a 9-to-5 weekday schedule. Many live in the neighborhoods hit hardest by COVID-19 that already lacked reliable and affordable transportation options.

LESSONS LEARNED? 

It’s clear the transportation decisions made during the protests had devastating impacts on many thousands of city residents. The IG report confirms they were made by Mayor Lightfoot, the police department, and Office of Emergency Management and Communications officials, often without genuine consultation with the city’s leading transportation officials. They weren’t rooted in any advance planning based on previous experience.

Current and future elected officials must learn valuable lessons from this experience: 

1. No more systemwide shutdowns. Transit is a public good and a necessity at all times and should be treated as such. Shutting it down should never be the solution and creates undue hardships, especially for people with disabilities, essential workers, and Black and Brown Chicago residents.

2. Ensure elected officials and transit agencies retain control over operations. During crises, elected officials must consult transit agency leaders and ensure they retain control of operational decisions, while taking emergency management and public safety factors into consideration. They know the system and the people who rely on it firsthand and should be at the forefront of operations decision making. This protocol could be part of transit management plans to address system issues during future crises.

Both of these points were emphasized in a petition to the mayor and Chicago-area transit agencies last October. Chicago’s transit systems must remain safe and reliable providers of mobility and access, whether through the course of an average day, a public health crisis, or during lawful protests.

According to the National Lawyers Guild of Chicago, legal precedent has found that public transportation is “necessary to the health, safety and public welfare of the people.”

Freedom of movement is freedom.

Photo courtesy of Evan Garcia/WTTW News